I am a bit
confused, a bit annoyed. Probably you all can help me get the answers I search
for. Here’s a short story.
An adventurous
man quite fun-loving once decided to visit a nearby wildlife sanctuary at
night, at the gate he was warned of wild beasts inside but he ignored and went
in, had a bit fun, roamed around enjoyed the sparkling moonlight waterfalls, on
his way back he was attacked by a big wild devilish beast and before the
officials could take situation in control, he was severely injured, down to his
knees fighting his survival and he did manage to survive. Even years after this
incidence, that man curses every other creature apart the homo sapiens
especially the whole bunch of wild animal kingdom for his sufferings. On being
asked why so, he in a frustapa mode curses every animal especially the wild
ones for his miseries. He has all rights to enter the sanctuary at night and
enjoy and the beast that attacked him had no right morally or ethically to
sabotage him thus every beast of his kind must be punished.
Now my mind
stops working, it’s full of arguing thoughts. Where is the fault in the system,
was it the gatekeeper’s fault that he couldn’t stop him from entering the
sanctuary at night or it was the man’s fault himself to ignore the warning. Definitely
the beast deserves no mercy, it had sinned going out its limits and attacking
an innocent man, but could it have been avoided, the man paid no attention to
the issued warning and was victimized. And should the victim treat every other
beast as a criminal or harbinger of his sorry fate?????
Now, why
does an undergrad at kgp worrying so much of this story? Well, some of you
might have guessed the context too ( http://shikhasinghiitkgp.blogspot.in/2012/07/to-men.html) .
Just replace the man with a sweet girl and the wildlife sanctuary by a night bar and the beast with a heavily drunk bully of the same kind. The girl enters the bar, is issued a warning too that it’s not safe inside, still she enters not wanting to cancel her fun plans and is victimized by a misbehavior by the drunk bully. Seems a similar story, just the characters have changed. Now the girl curses the whole male community for her sorry fate that does include me too.
Just replace the man with a sweet girl and the wildlife sanctuary by a night bar and the beast with a heavily drunk bully of the same kind. The girl enters the bar, is issued a warning too that it’s not safe inside, still she enters not wanting to cancel her fun plans and is victimized by a misbehavior by the drunk bully. Seems a similar story, just the characters have changed. Now the girl curses the whole male community for her sorry fate that does include me too.
Wait a
minute, in what universe did the billions of XY-chromosomed people declare that
bully as our representative, hum maante hain ki aisa karne wala kutta hai, he behaved as a bloody
motherfucker and has sinned heavily and must be punished but dear madam, where
does the question of sexism rise. What the hell other billions of males have done
to you, we support your cause and sympathize and if needed stand for you
against that bully. But, you can’t blame me or anyone of my kind for your
miseries. Yeah, I do agree, eve-teasing or other forms are shameful but common
and that’s why the society on its own tries to have a control system and as a
result of that, you did receive a warning too which you ignored for whatsoever
reason. The beast was in the bar waiting to haunt you and succeeded thanks to
your ignorance.
The first
rule in driving is ‘drive slow’ although you are an expert in driving, the
reason being others might not be good drivers and hit you hard really hard, it’s
not your fault but you will be hurt for sure. Same principle applies here too.
Follow the rules of the system. Now, some of my female friends argue that the
system is sexist in itself where all the rules are favored to the male side,
but it ever occur to you that the number of wild male beasts is way above the
number of wild female beasts (yes, some are there), so the rules have been
designed to protect our sisters and mothers.
Some black
curses in the society can’t be removed at one go, that’s why we create a
control system to act as a buffer while we work on eliminating those wild
beasts. So, let’s work together to control it rather than fight among
ourselves. And yes, this post isn’t sexist.
context is bit inappropriate beacuse wild animals behaviour is justified by nature but ours not.. while i agree to one point of urs that whole men community should not be held responsible .. but denies the fact that victim should be held responsible in any sense.
ReplyDeletedubey ji, i agree to the point that the victim can't be held responsible and i sympathize with her, and as long as comparing the men beasts to wild animals is concerned, i was talking about the ideology that both are equally wrong by nature, a wild man is wild by nature, u cant tame him, u have to punish
Delete"no words"
ReplyDeletejust
/_\ /_\
That it is not right to blame the entire community of men for the act, agreed; but I don't feel the comparision of a bar with a wildlife sanctuary (implying that bars are meant for men) is appropriate.
ReplyDeleteby that comparison, all i implied that the 'particular moment' at both places was not safe and warning was up
DeleteYour analogy has one main flaw: You are neglecting attacker's primal instinct.
ReplyDeleteSecond, the issue is why was there such a sign? Had it been your sister and you were the manager, would your attitude still be a "sign"?
no i am not neglecting, i am actually stressing on that point only that both share the same wild instinct.....and my dear friend, didnt your mother stop your sister or even you from moving out at night sometime in your past just for your safety, grow up dude, we are not in a Utopian era, all things aren't perfect, all men aren't perfect, so we have better protect the fairer sex and as i said make a buffer zone to clean things up
DeleteJust a very flawed comparison.
ReplyDeletecomparisons are always between two unequal but similar things, so flaws are a must, the similarities and the concept matters ma'm, and i don't mind if you call it flawed, its just and completely rational
Delete